pdf of How Christ Gives Church Its Doctrines e-Book of How Christ Gives Church Its Doctrines link to How Christ Gives Church Its Doctrines
How Christ Gives Church Its Doctrines
Pastor’s Report – November 8, 1978
How Christ Gives Church Its Doctrines

by Herbert W. Armstrong

I had not realized it before, but I find that somehow there seems to have been a supposition among some – more or less, I do not know to what extent – in the Ministry to assume that Church DOCTRINE is set by the Church.

This is MOST IMPORTANT – for God commands through the Apostle Paul that in the Church we must ALL SPEAK THE SAME THINGS, that there be no divisions among us.

It ought to be obvious that for ABSOLUTE DOCTRINAL UNITY, the doctrines, practices, customs should be PUT INTO the Church by Jesus Christ, the living HEAD of the Church.

It is apparent that, in the ministry, we were NOT all speaking the same thing – or at least in harmony and of one mind doctrinally.

I quote from a letter from Dr. Robert Kuhn. “After much consideration, I feel that it is proper that I should personally take full responsibility for the Systematic Theology Project. I was the primary participant and therefore must accept full responsibility for all its aspects,… Mr. Armstrong, please believe what I wanted to do. My sole desire has always been to support you and help the Church doing God’s Work. The circumstances surrounding the Systematic Theology Project were exceedingly complex from its inception as an effort to thwart the ministerial dissention and silence the doctrinal critics in 1974 to the writing of the papers (and the editing) during the time of your illness in late 1977. Throughout my personal objective was always to simply, powerfully and wholeheartedly uphold Church doctrine in the most effective manner. However I failed in this, I come before you, the Ministry and the Church to ask forgiveness.”

I gather from Dr. Kuhn’s letter that it was assumed that the doctrines of the Church are those agreed on by a group of ministers at Headquarters.

His letter continues, “My only goal in coordinating the project was to bring doctrinal consistency, stability and unity to the Ministry and the Church during a very traumatic and protracted period.”

That brings me to say this:

1) The very fact that such a project was contemplated, planned, or being worked on, was deliberately kept from me by my son – and many top-ranking ministers were demoted, or shanghaied away from Pasadena, and threatened with termination of their ministry if they contacted in any way.

As God is my witness, I KNEW NOTHING ABOUT any such project being produced. I knew absolutely nothing about it – or that there was such a project – or what it contained – until some months after it had been handed out to the Ministry at the January Conference. Prior to the Conference I asked my son Garner Ted point blank if any doctrinal matters were to be discussed in any way – as they had been the year before after I had been maneuvered to fly to Europe the afternoon of the opening day, after having addressed the Conference at its opening morning session. My son assured me nothing of a doctrinal nature would in any way be brought up. But it was brought up, and I find now that hours were spent in discussing and explaining doctrines in this “STP”.

Now I am told by Dr. Kuhn that the whole project was intended to bring the Ministry into harmony and unity (so all would speak the same thing). And BY WHAT METHOD?

That is the crux of the matter! The entire mistake was in, apparently, assuming that what a group of ministers at Headquarters, under my son, could determine Church doctrine, and if necessary to satisfy certain ones who did not want to accept what had been Church doctrine all along, to COMPROMISE, by WATERING DOWN God’s Truth!

Dear Fellow Ministers, this is the Church OF GOD, with Jesus Christ its LIVING Head – not the church of MEN, bargaining, discussing, compromising, altering and watering down doctrines to please MEN!

Perhaps I myself should take part of the blame for not sooner having made CLEAR AND PLAIN precisely H O W God put His Truth and doctrines into His Church. I simply did not realize that this was not understood.

Up until this conspiracy was done and an attempt to alter certain doctrines to please certain ministers, HOW DID God put His doctrines, beliefs, customs and practices into His Church? ANSWER: THROUGH JESUS CHRIST AND HIS CHOSEN APOSTLE!

Now was that GOD’s WAY? Let the Word of God tell us. And incidentally, let me first interject here, if any minister does not wholeheartedly agree with any doctrine, the solution is not to COMPROMISE or WATER DOWN – but to BE SURE we have what JESUS CHRIST has put into the Church. The solution, then, is for any such minister to come to Pasadena – or Tucson if I am there at that time – and prayerfully and sincerely go over it together. If your mind is as open as is mine, we will both come to the same mind – the mind of CHRIST! I will never compromise with God’s Truth – but my mind will always be open to PROOF of what is that truth. I have proved that if, being human myself, I have been wrong on a point, I WILL CHANGE TO THE TRUTH!

Peter and Paul, and the other original Apostles were also human and subject to mistakes. Yet the Church received ALL its doctrines, teachings, and practices THROUGH THOSE APOSTLES! THERE IS NOT ONE EXAMPLE OF THE CHURCH RECEIVING ITS BELIEFS ANY OTHER WAY!

Jesus Christ DID NOT APPOINT A DOCTRINAL COMMITTEE of MEN or ministers to manufacture and give the Church doctrine! Jesus Christ taught Peter and the original twelve IN PERSON, the same Christ taught Paul IN PERSON! Christ is the PERSONAL Word of God. The Bible is that same Word IN WRITING!

I followed Paul’s example.

And I can say, with him, “But I certify you, brethren, that the gospel which was preached of me is not after man. For I neither received it of man, neither was I taught it, but by the revelation of Jesus Christ… But when it pleased God, who… called me by His grace, to reveal His Son in me, that I might preach Him among the heathen; immediately I conferred not with flesh and blood. Neither…” went I to a Biblical Seminary, but I went into night-and-day study of the Word of God, mostly on my knees. (Galatians 1:11-17).

The Apostle Paul says, verse 17, that instead of going to other MEN, he went into Arabia. Apparently Jesus Christ, IN PERSON, manifested Himself and taught Paul there. For Paul said later,”…Have I not seen Jesus Christ our Lord…?” (1 Cor. 9:1). ”…And that He rose again the third day according to the scriptures; and that He was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve: …And last of all He was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time” (1 Cor. 15:4-6,8).

The twelve original Apostles received their teaching direct from Jesus IN PERSON. The Apostle Paul spent some three years in Arabia, and apparently that was the time when he saw JESUS IN PERSON, and was taught directly by Jesus Christ. But as Jesus is the Word in Person, so the Bible is the Word of God IN PRINT.

Now back to Galatians 1; “Then after three years (in Arabia) I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, and abode with him fifteen days. But other of the Apostles saw I none, save James the Lord’s Brother” (Gal. 1:18-19). Continue on, “Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also. And I went up by revelation, and communicated to them that gospel which I preach among the Gentiles, but privately to them which were of reputation, lest by any means I should run, or had run, in vain. But contrariwise, when they saw that the gospel of the uncircumcision (to the Gentiles) was committed unto me, as the gospel of the circumcision (Israel) was unto Peter; For he that wrought effectually in Peter to the apostleship of the circumcision, the same was mighty in me toward the Gentiles” (Gal. 2:1-8).

The word “apostle” means ”one sent forth.”

The meaning here is unmistakable – as Peter was the chief Apostle to Israel and Judah, so Paul was chief Apostle to the Gentiles.

Nevertheless, when All of the Scriptures on the subject are put together, it becomes certain that Peter, in fact, was the over-all chief Apostle.

The New Testament Church of God received all its teachings, practices, customs, FROM THE APOSTLES, with Peter chief over all the others.

I know well, that, in view of Roman Catholic teachings regarding Peter being the first pope, this statement will be challenged by many – but it is TRUE, nevertheless!

Peter did have primacy as chief Apostle! I shall amply prove that. YET PETER WAS NOT A POPE! There is a vast DIFFERENCE!

Remember, an Apostle is “ONE SENT FORTH WITH THE GOSPEL”. The Roman Catholic pope sits permanently, unless, as some few have done, he takes a trip to some other place – not as carrying the Gospel, but as a POLITICAL HEAD OF STATE.

Yet the Apostles were the teachers, who instilled in the Church the BELIEFS, TEACHINGS, PRACTICES AND CUSTOMS of the Church. And all members of the Church were required by God to BELIEVE, and SPEAK THE SAME THING!

In the Church at Corinth, Paul began his letter, INSPIRED as part of GOD’S WORD, by saying, “Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you” (1 Cor. 1:10).

Paul’s letter to the Corinthians was CORRECTIVE, as were his letters to other churches, and he was inspired to speak in the name of and AUTHORITY of Jesus Christ. For, he said, (verses 11-12), ”…that there are contentions among you.” ”…that every one of you saith, I am of Paul; and I of Apollos; and I of Cephas; and I of Christ.” THEY WERE BEGINNING TO FOLLOW INDIVIDUAL LEADERS. They supposed those leaders differed in their teaching, though in fact those mentioned did all speak and teach THE SAME THING as CHRIST had instructed.

SOURCE of Church Beliefs

Let’s GET THIS STRAIGHT; once and for all! The SOURCE of the beliefs, teachings, customs and practices in the Church of God is GOD HIMSELF! Not any man. Jesus said, “I have spoken nothing of myself,” – the FATHER had instructed Him! Jesus, in turn, taught His Apostles in Person!

THERE WAS NO DOCTRINAL BOARD! The teachings of the Church did not come from a COUNCIL of ministers and/or lay members, who voted on what to believe.

Right here, SOME are going to ask, “WHAT ABOUT ACTS 15? Wasn’t that the first Church Council at Jerusalem, to settle points of doctrine? THE ANSWER IS NO! And I intend to devote enough space in this article to clear up that point!

So far, I have shown you from Galatians 1 and 2 that Peter was the chief Apostle to the House of Israel, and Paul to the Gentiles. Now I will show you that Peter actually had PRIMACY OVER ALL.

At the very founding of the New Testament Church of God, it was PETER who stood up and explained what had occurred – preaching the first sermon in the Church that led to 3,000 converts (Acts 2:14-39).

A day or two later, the number became 5,000. It was Peter who said to the cripple; “In the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth rise up and walk” (Acts 3:6). It was PETER who preached the sermon to the crowd thus attracted that converted 2,000 more.

Next came the incident of Ananias and Saphira, stealing and lying. It was PETER who spoke and caused them to drop dead.

Next, when signs and wonders were performed by the Apostles. It was PETER’S SHADOW, as he passed by, that healed the sick.

Next, the Apostles were brought before the high priest and the council, and the spokesman for the Apostles was PETER, who said, “We ought to obey God rather than man.”

Coming to Acts 8, when Philip, then a deacon, went to Samaria, and when the people believed Philip preaching the things concerning the Kingdom of God, they were baptized. It was Peter and John who went down to Samaria, laid hands on the newly baptized (Gentiles) and prayed for the Holy Spirit to be given to them. This is the first example of the Church of God custom of laying hands on the baptized for receiving the Holy Spirit – and Peter was the leader, for when Simon the sorcerer tried to buy an apostleship with money, it was PETER who said to him (the first pope), “Thy money perish with thee… for I perceive that thou art in the gall of bitterness, and in the bond of iniquity.” He was the pater or peter – papal – pope of the Babylonian Mystery religion. Paul cites (II Thes. 2:7) “For the mystery of iniquity doth already work.” That religion, having without authority appropriated the name “Christianity” is named, in Revelation 17:5, “MYSTERY BABYLON THE GREAT.”

Is it not ironic that the one who rebuked and condemned the first pope was Cephas, whom Christ had called PETER?

But continue on.

We come to Acts 10. Although Paul was later to be made an Apostle to the Gentiles, the time had come to first open salvation to the Gentiles officially. And this was done by PETER, not Paul. It was Peter whom God sent to the house of the Gentile Cornelius, to teach him. It was Peter who convinced the others at Jerusalem that God had opened salvation to the Gentiles. As in, Acts 11.

UNDERSTAND THIS about Peter. He WAS NOT A PROUD RULING POPE. He was a humble man, strong in Christ’s Gospel and faith, but he did not try to lord it over others, or always take the top seat, unless his position required. He was HUMAN, still, though since the day of Pentecost he had the Holy Spirit. When Peter came to Antioch, more than 14 years after founding of the Church, his human nature showed when he withdrew from the Gentiles, after some Jewish converts arrived from Jerusalem. Paul rebuked Peter publicly for this. But then, we might well remember that Paul was also human. This event occurred in the chief Gentile Church, and Paul was a little nettled at seeing Peter withdraw from eating with Gentiles because some had arrived from Jerusalem. This incident reflects the humanity of both Peter and Paul – and demonstrates, also, that Peter was not a pope, else Paul would never have dared rebuked him.

Now we come to that crucial 15th chapter of Acts.

Few in God’s Church have fully understood this chapter. I shall go into sufficient detail to MAKE IT CLEAR!

Notice, verse1: “Certain men which came down from Judaea taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.” Who were these men? Not apostles, or they would have been named.


The Apostle Paul KNEW WELL that God gave His Church its teachings only though Christ and the Apostles. Immediately Paul withstood these unauthorized “teachers”.

Verse 2: “When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they (probably the local members, not fully realizing that Paul, being Apostle to the Gentiles, had authority to settle it) determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.”

These men from Judaea were undoubtedly Jewish Christians who had not received authentic teaching through Apostles – nor did they recognize Paul’s authority as an Apostle, or they would not have entered into such disputation with him.

Undoubtedly, being Jewish converts, without full Apostolic teaching, they looked on the Church as merely an extension of Judaism. Incidentally, the Judaism of that time WAS NOT Mosaic teaching. But after the days of Ezra and Nehemiah, the only organized Jewish religion was among the descendents of the contingent of Jews sent back to Jerusalem from Persian captivity (see Ezra 1:1-3) 70 years after the destruction of Solomon’s temple, to build the second temple – to which Jesus later came. After Ezra and Nehemiah, the rabbis gradually made a considerable change in the Old Covenant religion given Israel by Moses.

Their Israelite ancestors had always wanted to be more like the world around them. In 1 Samuel 8 you will read of how they wanted a king, and government more like the other nations of the world. Now the WORLD, except for Israel, which was especially called by God, was CUT OFF from God. God, in effect, had said to Adam, “You have rejected me and my Government. Therefore, I SENTENCE you to 6,000 years of being cut off from me. GO, form your own religions, your own governments, your own society and civilization.” That applied to all except those God specially called. God called Abraham, Moses, Abraham’s descendants the Israelites – but even the Israelites wanted to be like the worldly nations CUT OFF from God. Remember, all those centuries and millenniums, the Chinese, Japanese, people of India, Southeast Asia, Africa, the Roman Empire, knew little or nothing about GOD. They all had their own religions, and most were derived, with some changes, from that established by Semiramis, the mother-wife of Nimrod (Gen. 10).

Now these pagan religions – of Egypt, Greece, Babylon, Rome, had known nothing of God’s GRACE – unmerited, underserved PARDON, forgiveness of past sins on repentance. Instead, their religions had adopted a system of self-inflicted punishment, ordeal or torture, to justify past sins.

Moses had been used of God to give Israel certain laws. First, there was the over-all spiritual law of LOVE, or the Ten Commandments – although Israel without the Holy Spirit could keep that law only in the strictness of the letter (in the New Testament it must be according to the Spirit – or the obvious intent). This is called in the Bible the Law of God. Then, through Moses, God gave them the “law of Moses” – a sacrificial law of animal sacrifices, which could not justify sin, but were a reminder of sin, and was a physical substitute for the sacrifice of Christ. When Christ died on the cross, animal sacrifices ceased.

There also was a ceremonial law – of physical rituals – carnal ordinances, meat and drink offerings, etc. – to teach them the HABIT of obedience – things to do repeatedly morning, noon, and night. The law of rituals, including circumcision, was PHYSICAL, and a substitute until the Holy Spirit should be given, to teach them the HABIT of obedience.

In Galatians 3:19, this law was ADDED, because of transgressions. That is, transgressions of the spiritual LAW. In Galatians 3:24, this ritual law is called a “schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ.” In Romans and Galatians, the term “works of the law” always refers to these PHYSICAL laws, which were temporary until Christ. Sometimes the single word “works” means “good works,” in accord with the Spiritual Law, and sometimes the “works of the law” when mentioned in the context will for brevity speak of just “the law,” but the context will make it plain the subject is the RITUALS. The Greek for “works” of the law is ergon, which means physical effort.

Besides these temporary physical rituals, and sacrifices, God gave them through Moses statutes and judgments – the CIVIL LAWS of their nation. They were not necessarily temporary, or substitutional, but were to last as long as the NATIONAL GOVERNMENT was administered over the nation Israel.

Now the rabbis, after Ezra and Nehemiah, added some 65 “do’s and don’ts”, even to the keeping of the Sabbath. They adopted the PAGAN PENANCE – self inflicted punishment – and construed the physical rituals as a means of justification of past sins. THIS WAS JUDAISM – something really quite different from the religion of Moses.

Now back to Acts 15.

These Jews who had come down to Antioch still thought this system of PENANCE was still in effect. In Galatians 5:3, Paul shows that if a man was circumcised as a legal ritual, he became a debtor to do the WHOLE RITUAL LAW – and the context is speaking of the RITUAL law, though this verse does not use “works of the law”.

Paul was quite willing to take this to Jerusalem, BECAUSE PETER WAS THERE AT THE TIME.

This visit of Paul to Jerusalem is undoubtedly the one mentioned in Galatians 2. Apparently, according to Galatians 2:9, the only Apostles at Jerusalem at that time were Peter, James and John.

But in Acts 15:4, it is stated: “And when they were come to Jerusalem, they were received of the church and of the apostles and elders…”

Then, verse 6, “And the apostles and elders came together for to consider of this matter.” All ordained ministers are called “elders” in the Bible. This means the lay members were excluded, but the apostles and ordained ministers, ranked lower than the apostles, came together in this Council.

Now we see, that even these elders were not clear on this matter of circumcision. For, verse 7: “And when there had been much disputing, PETER rose up” and settled the matter!

Continue, verse 7-11: ”…PETER rose up, and said unto them, Men and brethren, ye know how that a good while ago God made choice among us, that the Gentiles by my mouth should hear the word of the gospel, and believe, and God, which knoweth the hearts, bear them witness, giving them the Holy Spirit, even as he did unto us: and put no difference between us and them, purifying their hearts by faith. Now therefore why tempt ye God, to put a yoke upon the neck of the disciples, which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear? But we believe that through the GRACE (not ritual penance) of the Lord Jesus Christ we shall be saved, even as they.”

Verse 12: “Then all the multitude kept silence.” PETER had settled the question!

Right here, NOTE CAREFULLY! Peter was an Apostle – ONE SENT FORTH proclaiming the Gospel, not a resident Pastor of a church. James was Pastor of the Jerusalem Church at the time, though also an apostle. Therefore James acted as chairman of the meeting – even though PETER gave the DECISION. As a matter of protocol, as chairman (as we would call it today), we come now to verse 13.

“And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Men and brethren, hearken unto me. Simeon (Peter) hath declared…” in other words, acting as chairman of the meeting, James in effect started by saying “PETER has declared” – Peter has settled it… “how God at the first did visit the Gentiles, to take out of them a people for his name.” Again, affirming Peter’s primacy – for when God decided to open salvation to the Gentiles – to CALL some of them to salvation, whereas heretofore God had called only Israelites (and even them NOT to salvation, except the prophets) – when God opened salvation to the Gentiles, He used Peter to do it! Now continue James’ speech:

“And to this agree the words of the prophets as it is written, after this I will return, and will build again the tabernacle of David, which is fallen down; and I will build again the ruins thereof, and I will set it up: that the residue of men might seek after the Lord, and all the Gentiles, upon whom my name is called, saith the Lord, who doeth all these things.”

James was quoting from Amos 9:11-12.

NOTE THIS! The Church of God is built on the FOUNDATION of the Apostles and the Prophets – Old Testament Prophets as well as the VERY FEW prophets of the New Testament. And James was here quoting from the prophet Amos, to add his own approval to Peter’s DECISION. James is not making the decision – he is making official Peter’s decision!

Continue: “Wherefore, my sentence is, that we trouble not them, which from among the Gentiles are turned to God: But that we write unto them, that they abstain from pollutions of idols, and from fornication, and from things strangled, and from blood.” (Verses 19-20). Pollutions of idols was related to idolatry, and idolatry and fornication were violations of the SPIRITUAL law, eternally binding. Eating blood or things strangled was NO PART of the ceremonial law, but a law of health which was not substitutionary.

OBSERVE SPECIALLY: This was not a matter, as did happen at Pasadena, of one of lower rank appointed by an Apostle, while the Apostle was in another part of the world, calling together a conference of ministers of various ranks – all under that of Apostle – and determining, or changing doctrine – watering down God’s TRUTH – and sending it out, as the STP was, claiming falsely and without authority that it was an authoritative doctrinal pronouncement!

In this case, it was PETER, chief Apostle, who set the decision. The letter they then sent to the Church at Antioch specified that this decision was inspired by the HOLY SPIRIT. PETER set it, James, local Pastor acting as chairman of the meeting, confirmed Peter’s decision, making it OFFICIAL, inspired by the HOLY SPIRIT.

Jesus Gave Peter Primacy

In all these successive instances, I have shown you, step by step, that Peter was LEADER of the Apostles – and that the Church received its teachings and doctrines FROM THE APOSTLES!

But God has always worked primarily through ONE MAN at a time – as Abraham, then Isaac, then Jacob, then Joseph – later Moses, then Joshua, later Samuel, then David – and, in the New Testament Church, PETER. But Peter was an Apostle – one sent forth proclaiming the Message – not a resident pope over a political hierarchy.

Now notice how JESUS gave Peter primacy over Apostles:

Jesus had asked His Apostles-to-be whom they said Jesus really was. “And Simon Peter answered and said, Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God. And Jesus said unto him” – UNTO PETER: “Blessed art thou Simon Barjona, for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee, but my Father which is in heaven. And I say also unto thee” – UNTO PETER –” That thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of the grave shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto THEE” – PETER, not the Church – “the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatsoever thou” – PETER – “shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever thou” – PETER – “shalt loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven.”

There has been much discussion at Pasadena between certain ministers of lower than Apostle rank, as to the CHURCH binding and loosing.

So now let it be MADE OFFICIAL – by Christ’s present-day Apostle – that this binding and loosing PLAINLY, CLEARLY, was given to Christ’s chief APOSTLE – not to lower-rank ministers ordained by his authority – not by the CHURCH as a body – but by the APOSTLE!

When men who held office under the Apostle, and by his appointment or approval, took it into their own hands, in his absence – stealthily KEEPING IT FROM HIM – act to water down God’s TRUTH, alter His doctrines, assume unauthorized authority, then the living CHRIST moves His Apostle to ACT SWIFTLY, to PUT OUT the prime mover in this conspiracy, and under Christ, set God’s Church and Work BACK ON GOD’S TRACK!

PRAISE THE ETERNAL GOD! He has NOT left nor forsaken HIS CHURCH! Jesus Christ still REIGNS SUPREME in God’s Church, as He shall, very soon, reign over all the earth!

Many harmful errors in the “STP” still remain to be PUT STRAIGHT – and it shall be done by JESUS CHRIST, through His Apostle, as rapidly as is humanly possible!

JESUS CHRIST is the living HEAD of this Church! HE built it through His Apostle. And He, CHRIST, still rules SUPREME in the one and only area on earth where the GOVERNMENT OF GOD is being administered today!